November 17, 2026
  TOMS RIVER – Toms River’s affordable housing dispute has moved into a new phase in court, and tensions over it spilled into the most recent Township Council meeting.   Fair Share Housing Center has asked a judge to enforce a December 2025 settlement and revoke the township’s immunity from builder’s remedy lawsuits. Two developers have The post Court Filings Complicate Toms River’s Affordable Housing Demands appeared first on Jersey Shore Online.

  TOMS RIVER – Toms River’s affordable housing dispute has moved into a new phase in court, and tensions over it spilled into the most recent Township Council meeting.

  Fair Share Housing Center has asked a judge to enforce a December 2025 settlement and revoke the township’s immunity from builder’s remedy lawsuits. Two developers have also filed papers asking to join the case.

  Builder’s remedy immunity protects a municipality from certain lawsuits by developers. Those suits seek approval for projects that exceed local zoning when a town hasn’t met its affordable housing obligations.

Closed-Door Session Sparks Accusations

  Before the public meeting, council members and the mayor met behind closed doors with attorneys and retired Superior Court Judge Mark Troncone. Troncone is serving as mediator on the township’s affordable housing plan.

  Mayor Daniel Rodrick later accused council members of telling the mediator they would not advance his administration’s proposals because the political fallout would land on him. “They actually told a retired Superior Court judge, right to his face in executive session, that they were doing this because I would have to ‘wear it’ politically,” Rodrick said in a statement.

  There is a power struggle between four council members that make up a council majority, and Rodrick, his administration, and three council members.

  Councilman Clinton Bradley, one of the council members on the other side of the fence from Rodrick, said he couldn’t talk about what happened behind closed doors, and instead pointed to concerns the council has raised publicly. Those include transferring township-owned land, financial commitments and the council being left out of negotiations.

  “We are bound by executive session not to repeat what happens in there,” said Councilman Robert Bianchini. “If anything, it’s the mayor trying to make this political. I said publicly that this is the mayor’s plan and he hasn’t presented anything that is in the best interests of all Toms River residents.”

Mayor Daniel Rodrick, Business Administrator Jonathan Salonis & Attorney Paul Pascarella (Photo by Stephanie Faughnan)

Fair Share Seeks Enforcement; Township Wants More Time

  Fair Share alleges Toms River failed to carry out parts of the December 2025 settlement. It wants the court to require the township to implement its housing plan and Route 70 zoning ordinance. The group is also seeking an acceptable replacement for the Hope’s Crossing commitment, documentation for 70 affordable apartments at Gabrielle Run, reimbursement of legal fees and an end to the township’s immunity.

  The settlement called for about 670 apartments on Route 70 near the Lake Ridge adult community, including 134 affordable units. It also called for extending affordability restrictions on 110 existing Hope’s Crossing rentals, a commitment that later fell through. Fair Share says the two pieces represented about 325 affordable housing credits. The township’s November 2 filing puts the total at 327.25, including bonus credits.

  In that filing, the township acknowledges the Route 70 and Hope’s Crossing pieces remain unresolved. It asks the court to extend its temporary immunity through a December 7 hearing and to recognize other parts of its plan. These include a council-approved agreement to convert 19 market-rate apartments at Autumn Ridge to affordable units. The township says those units may qualify for 19 additional bonus credits, and it is evaluating group-home beds for possible credits.

Route 70 Plan Questioned

  Residents of the Lake Ridge senior community have raised concerns about the Route 70 site’s density, traffic and emergency access. Association president Michael Messina told the council that Rodrick had called him and said the parcels remained in the housing plan. Messina has sought clarification on whether the site near Route 70 and Massachusetts Avenue is still slated for development.

  Messina said residents believed the administration was pursuing alternatives to Route 70. “It is an extremely sad situation that Daniel Rodrick as a dictator has failed to come up with a plan that can be agreed upon by himself as mayor and the seven council people,” he told the council.

  Property owners along the corridor have also stepped in. On November 2, Krupnick Realty Holding Co. filed a motion to intervene on behalf of a group of owners with interests in Route 70 parcels. The filing says the township included much of the group’s property in its March housing plan without contacting the owners, then left it out of a later plan.

  The owners say their current concept calls for 375 homes, including 75 affordable units. The earlier plan contemplated 134 affordable units as part of a larger development. The court has not approved the proposal or ruled on the request to intervene.

A larger-than-usual crowd attended the October 28 Toms River Township Council meeting, where the township’s affordable housing plan and a Fair Share Housing Center court motion were discussed. (Photo by Stephanie Faughnan)

Route 9 Land

  Rodrick says his administration negotiated two all-affordable projects along Route 9 as alternatives. Velocity Affordables LLC would build up to 125 apartments, and OWL Construction/Route 9 Commons LLC would build up to 135. Both would require township-owned land and financial assistance.

  “All 100% affordable projects require very large subsidies,” Rodrick said. He explained that restricted rents generally can’t cover construction costs on their own. Public land, construction assistance and government loans are needed to make the projects work.

  The land is part of a larger tract the township bought in 2016 with a bond of about $10.3 million. Some council members and residents say it was purchased to prevent development. Rodrick says the parcels were not bought with dedicated open-space funds or set aside for preservation.

  The parcels do not appear on the township’s Recreation and Open Space Inventory, known as ROSI. At the October 28 meeting, the council adopted a resolution adding them to that list. Rodrick disputes that the resolution is legally binding.

  Council President David Ciccozzi said the council was not consulted on the administration’s proposals. “We were never part of this negotiation or any information, zero,” Ciccozzi said. Rodrick disputes that account and says the alternatives were developed partly in response to residents’ objections.

Hooper-Caudina Project

  Conifer Realty, which has a contract to buy privately owned land in the Hooper-Caudina Redevelopment Area, filed to intervene on October 21. Its proposal calls for 135 to 140 affordable apartments, with a preference for veterans. Unlike the administration’s Route 9 projects, it would not require township-owned land.

  The township has opposed Conifer’s request, arguing the company hasn’t supplied its purchase agreement. Rodrick also questioned whether the project is ready, saying Conifer hasn’t provided enough financial information. “Conifer hasn’t sent us anything like that either,” he said, referring to documents that would show the company can finance construction. “They are also about one year late to the table.”

What’s Next

  Part of the case had been scheduled for a November 18 hearing, but Fair Share has asked the court to postpone it because of scheduling conflicts. Separately, the township wants its temporary immunity extended through the December 7 hearing.

  As the case moves forward, the court will decide how Toms River must meet its affordable housing obligations. It will also decide whether the township stays protected from builder’s remedy lawsuits while the dispute plays out.

The post Court Filings Complicate Toms River’s Affordable Housing Demands appeared first on Jersey Shore Online.