TOMS RIVER – Thirteen months after a one-year-old French bulldog named Ruby was shot in the face inside a Berkeley Township home, Jeffrey Lentz, the stepfather of Ruby’s owner, stood in an Ocean County courtroom and admitted his role in her death. He pleaded guilty on November 16 to second-degree possession of a firearm for an unlawful purpose and third-degree animal cruelty.
Under the agreement, prosecutors will recommend five years in New Jersey State Prison on the weapons count, with one year of parole ineligibility. A three-year flat sentence on the animal cruelty charge would run at the same time. A third count, tied to a large-capacity ammunition magazine, will be dismissed.
Lentz will also be banned from owning, harboring or living with any animal and must have no contact with Ruby’s owners, identified in court only as NI and NG. Even as he admitted firing the fatal shot, he drew one firm line. He never meant to hurt her.

Racing The Plea Deadline
The deal came together with little time to spare. The case was listed for trial on January 12, and the window for negotiations was closing. At a November 2 hearing, Superior Court Judge Kimarie Rahill made that clear.
“I have to get permission from the presiding judge to adjourn a plea cutoff,” Rahill said. “We’re scheduled for trial for January.”
In New Jersey criminal courts, the plea cutoff is the final deadline for deals. Once it passes, negotiated offers generally come off the table. A defendant who wants to plead guilty after that usually has to admit to the full charges with no bargain or go to trial.
Assistant Prosecutor Eleni Demestihas asked for a short extension to try to reach a resolution. Superior Court Judge Guy P. Ryan, Ocean County’s Criminal Presiding Judge, approved it that same day.

One Word In The Hallway
By November 12, the two sides appeared close. Defense attorney Ali Homayouni, of the Law Office of Evan Nappen, said he expected a plea the following Monday afternoon. Demestihas said the state needed a little more time to file a Graves Act waiver and work through the process with Ryan.
She also confirmed prosecutors had spoken with the victims about the deal. Rahill granted the extra days but drew a firm line. Without a plea by Monday, the case would move past the cutoff and toward the January 12 trial.
Outside the courtroom, Lentz was seen in the hallway poring over paperwork. At one point, he could be heard saying the word “intent” out loud and nodded his head no. He also asked for someone to send him a sign. Intent, as it turned out, was the one thing he would not admit.

“To Startle Ruby”
On November 16, Lentz was sworn in and answered a series of questions from his attorney. He admitted he was home on October 3, 2025, when NG dropped Ruby off. He said he had several alcoholic drinks earlier that day and was carrying a firearm.
Lentz acknowledged pointing the gun in Ruby’s general direction on purpose. He said he only meant to startle her. Instead, a round went off, struck Ruby and killed her.
Homayouni followed with one more question. “But you never intended to kill or harm Ruby, correct?” he asked. “100% correct,” Lentz replied.
Demestihas pressed further. Lentz agreed Ruby was not his and that, in the eyes of the law, she belonged to NI and NG. He agreed that pointing a gun to startle her was an unlawful purpose and that he handled it recklessly, causing needless mutilation and her death.
What The Graves Act Waiver Means
The weapons charge falls under New Jersey’s Graves Act, which sets mandatory minimum prison time for certain gun crimes. For a five-year sentence, that normally means 42 months behind bars before parole eligibility. That was the state’s original offer back in January.
A Graves Act waiver allows prosecutors to ask the court for a lower minimum when the circumstances support it. Prosecutors said a signed waiver motion is now in place, which cuts the parole bar to one year. The waiver does not erase the conviction or the five-year term.
The two sides are also working out a consent order on selling the guns seized from the home. Lentz will be sentenced before Judge Ryan on January 22, 2027.

“We Still Don’t Have Ruby”
Ruby was supposed to spend one night at the home NI’s mother shared with Lentz while the NI and NG attended a wedding. According to the affidavit of probable cause, NG told detectives Lentz was pouring himself a Tito’s when he arrived that afternoon, with a small handgun in a red holster on his hip.
That evening, Lentz called to say Ruby was gone. He told officers she had slipped outside, run off and come back bleeding from the mouth. He later told a police officer she may have been hit by a car.
The evidence told a different story. A necropsy found an entry wound on the right side of Ruby’s muzzle and a bullet fragment lodged in her shattered jaw. Investigators found bloodstained carpets rolled up in the garage and two spent 9mm shell casings. Ruby died at an emergency animal hospital that night.
For NI, the plea is a milestone, not a victory lap. “Of course, I’m thrilled that this is a big stepping stone, not just for Justice for Ruby, but for the animal community as a whole and companion animals,” she said. “But at the end of the day, it’s not like [NG] and I are celebrating. We still don’t have Ruby.”

She credited the strangers who rallied behind the couple. “I just am so thankful for the massive support we received from the community,” NI said. “Without their letters, without their following, without their comments, we really wouldn’t have gotten here. It was really a group effort to get to this point.”
That support grew from a Facebook page called Justice for Ruby, which has drawn followers from around the world. Ruby’s story also reached Trenton. In March, local lawmakers introduced Assembly Joint Resolution 165 and Senate Joint Resolution 129 to name October 3, the day Ruby died, Companion Animal Cruelty Awareness Day. Both measures are still sitting in committee and have not come up for a vote.
NI said the fight continues long after sentencing. “I will be at every single parole hearing, every year, to make sure that he stays put,” she said. “It doesn’t stop here.”
The post Ocean County Man Pleads Guilty In Fatal Shooting Of Dog appeared first on Jersey Shore Online.
